Sunday, 23 October 2011

Actions or just active

On Friday we had our children's church. This is a 40 min service for children that follows a set pattern each week. We typically start with an opening prayer, then have some songs, some exploration of a biblical theme (often using godly play), a response to this in some craft form (play-doh is very popular at the moment!), some more songs and a closing prayer. Then we all go and eat cake.

LittleLanky certainly seems to be enjoying it and she along with the other children run to the chapel in their excitement to start. Always encouraging.

This week LankyAnglican led us in singing and one of the songs he chose was the Allelu, Allelu, Allelu, Alleluia; praise ye the lord (although we used more modern words which tripped up the adults considerably). Now this song can be split into two sections and you stand when it's your section to sing which involves a lot of bobbing up and down. LittleLanky loved it! She was shrieking with laughter at being thrown in the air and was trying to jump up and down at the right times. So this felt like a great success.

It then got me thinking about songs with actions as we discussed how the children would love them and I realised I don't like action songs. It is just my own inadequacies coming out but I don't know all the actions to any song and suddenly I felt like when I was a teenager and I didn't know all the actions to the Macarena (for the record, I don't think this is necessarily a problem!). So my problem with action songs is that they can make people feel excluded or just inept as they are trying to mime various animals.

I know there are ways round it to some extent - ie. someone teaching the actions at the front - but it still doesn't feel comfortable to me. The other thing I have noticed is that LittleLanky immediately starts getting more restrained if there are proper actions to a song because she doesn't like getting it wrong.

I'm not saying people shouldn't do actions to songs or prayer but it was a wonderful experience watching LittleLanky and the other children enjoying something as simple and jumping up and down to a song in church.

Thursday, 20 October 2011

Being lazy

One thing I discovered tonight in church is that if I want LittleLanky to stay connected with the service then I have to stay connected to.

It sounds obvious, but it becomes tempting to stay sitting down with her and playing rather than standing up for the hymns and the gospel etc. It is laziness on my part when I do this because it's easier. It's never a problem to play with her if she needs me but often she's playing very happily without me helping.

I often have to break off singing or reading a response to talk to LittleLanky or stop her from destroying something, so after a while I just let the service go on around me. There's nothing wrong with this in a way but I have realised that when I get disconnected, she does and when I make an effort to stay engaged with it, she does too because she's intrigued about what I'm doing.

So I resolve to try and stand up and not just be lazy and play with the godly play kits during the hymns. Although I will allow myself a bit of play time during the sermons - I often find them a little tedious too, so I know where she's coming from!

Playing or praying in church

As my previous post explained, I have become interested in how young children are incorporated into church worship. Older children tend to go out to some kind of Sunday School and young children are often sidelined a bit.

At LankyAnglican's theological college we are in the process of providing provision for the younger members of our congregation during our college services. The children who are 6+ normally go out during the service to a separate group and then come back in and the 0-5s stay in with their parents.

We have an area in the church that has had the pews removed and it is quite a large space. We put some rugs down and for the first three weeks brought lots of toys over for them to play with. We thought we were onto a winner, they would be entertained and we could concentrate on the service.

It's not worked out like that. LittleLanky was entranced for the first week, got bored after about 20 minutes the second week and spent the third week trying to climb over the pews at the back of church and shouting. And this was even after changing the toys round each week to stop them from getting bored. I noticed the same behaviour from her over the summer when we were attached to a placement church that also has a play area. I was bemused by the pattern of behaviour because she can concentrate very well and has often seemed to be understanding some of what goes on during services.

After thinking about it, I have concluded that she is just playing (nothing wrong in that in the slightest) but in her normal play I chat far more to her and she goes between activities very quickly. She has the normal attention span of a two year old, which is five minutes if you're lucky!

I don't expect her to be silent in church (it's never going to happen!) but I do want her to learn to be respectful of other people and to learn that there are times when people do want to be quiet in services, like prayer or sermons. I'd also like her to learn to appreciate the beauty of services. She already really enjoys many of things that happen during church services and gets excited about going to church. I suspect much of this enthusiasm will wear off once she can understand a sermon and has to sit in a pew rather than playing with play-doh on a comfy rug!

So the way in which we're changing the children's area is to reflect the service in a way in which 0-5s can understand. We had a successful trial tonight with a number of different sets of resources that appeared at different points during the service and I think the children seemed calmer and much more engaged than previous weeks. LittleLanky didn't go pew mountaineering this week anyway!

We have much more work to do in selecting the right resources for the different points during the service but I'm hoping we're onto something. I'll keep on updating the blog with my findings.

I could tell LittleLanky was more engaged this week with what was going on, because she watched very intently as the procession passed us on their way back into the vestry. However that may have been because she thought the candles were to celebrate her birthday (which she has just had) and that we were all going to sing happy birthday. But we'll never know!

Why am I doing this?

I ask myself this all the time! However in relation to this blog - I have decided to blog about my experiences of young children's worship in the Church of England. I have no professional qualifications in this field whatsoever. My husband is an ordinand in the Anglican Church (LankyAnglican) and we have a two year old daughter (LittleLanky) and we spend quite a lot of time in church services. I have never previously been interested by children's work and before LittleLanky's arrival didn't have much experience with Play-Doh but all that is changing.

I'm intrigued about how different churches tackle children in church. Some churches provide creches, some have children's areas at the back, some have an external place you can take your child (eg. Church hall, vestry etc), some have play bags that they give out and some have nothing. I only have a sample of one child to go on but I think from talking to other parents I'm not alone in my experiences of these.

Creches - great for some people, but not for us as a family. We all want to stay connected together and it's important for LittleLanky to see her Dad at the front of church (sometimes dressed in some odd clothing). So we don't use them.

Going out to other locations - often a necessity for practical things. Like LittleLanky shouting NO at the top of her voice every time the choir started their anthem while we were on placement. I think we all understood her feelings but we were polite enough to keep them contained. So it's great to have these spaces to take a child out to for practical reasons but I always feel very disconnected to the service even if they're relaying the service in there. And if I'm honest, sometimes these spaces end up being filled with chatting parents. Nothing wrong with that but it's not what I go to a church service for.

Play bags - these are great but have limited value in my experience. Brilliant for visiting children who have never been to that particular church before (or any church at all) and are intrigued by the contents and normally a little overawed by unfamiliar surroundings so normally stay close to parents.

Nothing - there's nothing wrong with having no special provision for children in your church in my opinion. Often churches have a diverse and changing population and if you have no children at a point in time it's difficult to see what you should provide. The thing I love in churches like this is if people point out that LittleLanky is very welcome and I should feel free to move around and not worry about keeping her quiet. I know that she is welcome in church, but it's lovely to be reaffirmed in this way. I do also try and keep her fairly quiet because I think it's the best way for her to appreciate the service but we're obviously not always successful as she is a normal two year old!

Children's area in church - this is my area of great interest at the moment. As I believe it's the ideal for LittleLanky to stay in the service, this is where I have ended up. The interesting thing is that her behaviour in these spaces is not generally very good. She tends to get bored by the toys very quickly and gets very loud and then tries to get to Daddy at the front. I know people say I should let her go to him but LittleLanky does like to chat to an audience and would be preaching the parable of Jesus and Thomas the Tank Engine if we let her get in the pulpit with Daddy, so for all our sakes we don't let her roam to the front of the church.

At LankyAnglican's theological college, I'm lucky enough to be working with a great group of people on children's church stuff and we're pleased with some of the things that we're trying.

My coming posts will explore some of the things that we're trying with the children. I will only really tell you about LittleLanky's responses to things as she is the only child I feel comfortable commenting on but I think her responses to it will be fairly indicative of the other children.